The Washington Commanders face a familiar offseason question: who complements Terry McLaurin as the No. 2 receiver? After relying on journeymen like Olamide Zaccheaus and Noah Brown in 2024, general manager Adam Peters has three distinct paths forward.

Brandon Aiyuk offers elite production with 153 catches and 2,357 yards over two seasons, but availability concerns persist. The 49ers hold him on the reserve/did not report list, and he hasn't played since tearing his ACL and MCL in October 2024. His $27 million cap hit looms large, though Peters' San Francisco background provides intel advantages.

Stefon Diggs brings proven NFL reliability after catching 85 passes for 1,013 yards last season with New England. His recent legal troubles ended in acquittal, and his Maryland roots create natural appeal. Meanwhile, third-round rookie Antonio Williams impressed at Clemson with 208 receptions and 21 touchdowns, though developing him might be risky with the coaching staff potentially coaching for their futures.

The decision hinges on Washington's timeline. Aiyuk could provide long-term stability if signed early, while Diggs offers immediate impact at age 33. Williams represents the developmental route, but with McLaurin's durability now in question after missing seven games last season, the Commanders may favor proven production over potential.