England lost 1-2 to Argentina in the World Cup semi-final after Anthony Gordon's early second-half lead was overturned by Enzo Fernandez and Lautaro Martinez. Thomas Tuchel suggested English football lacks the "DNA" to control games like Spanish or South American sides. Gary Neville strongly disagreed on the Stick to Football Podcast, citing Tuchel's decision to bench Kobbie Mainoo and omit technical players like Phil Foden, Cole Palmer, and Trent Alexander-Arnold. Neville argued Tuchel's defensive substitutions invited pressure and sent a negative message.

Neville acknowledged this pattern has plagued England for decades, referencing his own tournament experiences where teams retreated deep. He praised Lionel Messi's influence on the second goal but stressed England lack the technical quality to retain possession under elite pressure. Neville noted Jude Bellingham and Harry Kane had quiet nights.

Sky Sports News understands the FA are not reviewing Tuchel's position; he remains contracted for Euro 2028. Neville believes criticism of Tuchel's game management is legitimate but opposes calls for his removal, stating he never expected England to win the tournament.