Germany face a high‑profile gamble as Manuel Neuer returns to the squad for the World Cup 2026 at 40. The Bayern Munich goalkeeper, who retired after Euro 2024, was recalled on the eve of the tournament, replacing Oliver Baumann. A calf injury kept Baumann in warm‑up matches, but coach Julian Nagelsmann confirmed Neuer will start against Curaçao.

Neuer’s comeback follows a stellar Champions League run where he made 135 successful sweeps, more than any other keeper since 2010. His performance earned a Bayern contract extension and reignited debate over legacy versus risk. Former teammate Thomas Müller praised the sporting sense of the decision, noting communication flaws but underscoring Neuer’s enduring influence.

At 40, Neuer faces scrutiny as reaction times dip and age bites. Yet his discipline—early arrivals, late departures, massages, gym work—keeps him fit. If he mirrors his 2014 form, he could cement a spot among the greats; if not, the return may tarnish a storied career. Germany’s defense will feel his presence regardless.

The decision also tests Nagelsmann’s squad depth, as Oliver Baumann remains ready but out of favor. Fans debate whether Neuer’s presence will inspire confidence or distract from younger talent. With Germany’s recent group exit streak, the stakes are high: a strong showing could reset expectations, while a poor performance might confirm the risk was misplaced.