Chris Sutton insists Rangers hold a stronger claim to the Scottish Premiership title than Celtic despite trailing Hearts by four points. The former Celtic striker, who won the 2003 Uefa Cup final under Martin O'Neill, argues Celtic’s inconsistent form under O’Neill makes their title hopes unsustainable. Sutton, a vocal Scottish Premiership pundit, claims Rangers’ recent form—despite their current second-place position—gives them a better chance than Celtic, who haven’t beaten Rangers or Hearts in league matches this season. He dismisses suggestions Celtic can secure a title with four games left, stating, ‘I really don’t believe it.’

The narrative centers on a three-way battle between Rangers, Celtic, and Hearts, with the latter undefeated at Tynecastle this season. Sutton praises Hearts’ resilience under Derek McInnes, calling their home record ‘phenomenal’ and suggesting a win against Rangers could effectively end the latter’s title hopes. He contrasts this with Celtic’s inability to secure wins against their rivals, noting they lost to both Rangers and Hearts in league games. While bookmakers favor Rangers, Sutton emphasizes performances over form, arguing ‘each team is capable of not winning another game.’ His confidence in Hearts’ ability to ‘find a way’ underscores the unpredictability of the race.

Hearts’ dominance at home and McInnes’ managerial acumen are central to Sutton’s argument. He criticizes overemphasis on financial investment, asserting McInnes’ tactical decisions have been pivotal. For Sutton, the 14th title in 15 years for Celtic remains mathematically possible but unlikely given their current trajectory. He highlights the season’s peculiar nature, where none of the top three teams have won most weekends, making the finale unpredictable. While Rangers’ path isn’t guaranteed, Sutton believes their historical edge—combined with Celtic’s recent struggles—gives them a tangible advantage. The crux? Titles often hinge on single moments, and a Hearts-Rangers clash could decide everything.