HeadlinesBriefing favicon HeadlinesBriefing.com

Apple Battles $500M Patent Fee at UK Supreme Court

Financial Times Companies •
×

Apple heads to the UK Supreme Court on Monday to challenge a $502mn patent bill that the Court of Appeal ordered the iPhone maker to pay Optis for embedding mobile technology in its devices. The three-day hearing marks the climax of a years-long dispute over patents covering voice and data communication standards essential to modern smartphones.

The patents originated from telecom infrastructure companies Ericsson, Samsung and Panasonic, who sold them in stages to Optis, a entity owned by funds managed by New York's Brevet Capital. Licensing talks between Apple and Optis collapsed in 2019, leading the patent holder to sue in England where courts can set global royalty rates. The High Court initially awarded $56mn in 2023, but the Court of Appeal increased the sum ninefold using a Google licensing deal as reference.

Apple argues the appeals court's methodology was "arbitrary" and could stifle innovation across the mobile industry. The company claims its defeat would force other device makers to pay excessive royalties, ultimately hurting consumers through higher prices. Apple has assembled an unusual coalition including Intel and Hollywood studios to support its position.

Qualcomm opposes Apple's appeal, arguing the company departs from established licensing principles. The chipmaker warns that undermining FRAND (fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory) terms threatens incentives for future innovation. A panel of five judges including Lord Robert Reed will decide whether to uphold or overturn the nearly half-billion-dollar judgment.