HeadlinesBriefing favicon HeadlinesBriefing.com

Shaun Evans cleared after VAR hand gesture controversy

BBC Sport Football •
×

Video assistant referee Shaun Evans faced a wave of criticism after a broadcast showed him forming an upside‑down “OK” sign during the VAR hub feed in Dallas before Germany’s 7‑1 win over Curacao. Social media linked the gesture to white‑supremacy symbolism, prompting FIFA to launch an investigation.

FIFA concluded its review without finding any breach of the Disciplinary Code, stating there was no evidence Evans intended to convey any extremist message. Evans issued a statement insisting the movement was an "involuntary, subconscious twitch" and that he was unaware of its appearance on camera.

The Australian official emphasized that the backlash misrepresents his character, expressing regret over how the gesture was interpreted while maintaining he did not deliberately make the sign. He also noted the intense scrutiny that officials endure during high‑profile matches.

The episode underscores the heightened sensitivity surrounding symbols in football and the pressure on match officials to avoid even unintended controversies. Evans remains on the VAR roster, and the incident will likely influence future broadcast protocols for referee hubs.