Scotland boss Steve Clarke confronts significant selection dilemmas ahead of their World Cup 2026 opener against Haiti on June 14. With Billy Gilmour ruled out by a knee injury, only five players—Andy Robertson, Aaron Hickey, John McGinn, Scott McTominay, and Ben Gannon-Doak—appear guaranteed starters. Clarke must decide between a back four or back five formation, with Kieran Tierney's fitness potentially influencing this tactical choice.

The goalkeeping situation presents another challenge, with Craig Gordon and Angus Gunn competing for the starting position despite limited recent game time. Gordon, at 43, could become the second-oldest World Cup player if selected, while Gunn started at Euro 2024. Both keepers have struggled for regular club football this season, raising concerns about match sharpness.

Up front, Clarke has five options to lead the line: Lawrence Shankland, Che Adams, Lyndon Dykes, George Hirst, and Ross Stewart. Shankland leads the form charts with 20 club goals this season, but Clarke typically prioritizes loyalty, favoring experienced forwards Adams and Dykes who have combined for nearly 100 Scotland caps. The midfield balance question remains, with McTominay and McGinn both preferring advanced roles despite their international effectiveness.