The 30‑game NWSL season has reached its halfway point, giving ESPN a full slate to issue report cards for all 16 teams. Each club now has enough data to earn a grade that reflects true performance.

Angel City FC earned a C+ after a shaky start and the mid‑season dismissal of coach Alexander Straus. The team sits in eighth place, just above the playoff line, and will need a stable coaching situation to break into the top tier.

Bay FC received a C as it continues a multi‑year rebuild. With the addition of USWNT midfielder Claire Hutton and rookie talents like Kennedy Fuller, the expansion side shows promise despite inconsistent results.

Defending champions Gotham FC topped the list with an A. The club remains in the NWSL Shield race and boasts a strong roster, though recent departures and injuries have tested their depth. Overall, the grades reveal a league in transition, with some teams on the rise and others still fighting to find consistency.