Phillies president Dave Dombrowski called Bo Bichette's move to the rival Mets a 'gut punch' after the shortstop spurned Philadelphia for a $126 million, three-year deal with New York. The two-time All-Star was expected to join a potent Phillies lineup featuring Kyle Schwarber, Bryce Harper, and Trea Turner.

Dombrowski admitted the Phillies were close to a deal but never reached a signed agreement. The Mets' offer included opt-out clauses and no deferred money, a structure the Phillies traditionally avoid. Bichette can opt out after the first or second season, making this a short-term gamble for New York.

Philadelphia quickly pivoted by re-signing catcher J.T. Realmuto to a $45 million contract. Dombrowski noted the organization remains confident after also retaining Schwarber this offseason. With the core returning, the Phillies believe they are set for another run in the NL East despite missing on their top free-agent target.