A San Luis Obispo County judge has ruled that a paddleboarder charged with assaulting a surfer will face trial. Andrew Eric Gustafson, 60, is accused of attacking Haylee Red-Van Rooyen on August 23, 2025, at Morro Strand State Beach. Gustafson allegedly knocked Red-Van Rooyen off her surfboard, hit her with his paddle, and forced her head underwater. The incident was initially investigated as a misdemeanor but was later upgraded to attempted murder before being reduced to felony assault charges.

Red-Van Rooyen testified in court, describing the harrowing experience. She detailed how Gustafson, after ramming into her, chased her and struck her with his paddle. He then jumped on her board, forcing her head underwater while shouting expletives. Her account underscores the severity of the alleged assault and the emotional toll it took on her. Gustafson's lawyer argued for a reduction in charges, citing no prior criminal record and lack of lasting damage, but the judge denied this motion.

The case highlights ongoing tensions between surfers and paddleboarders, with some experts noting that such incidents, while rare, can escalate quickly due to territorial behavior in the water. The trial is set to continue, with a pre-trial arraignment scheduled for March 2. This incident emphasizes the need for better communication and respect among water sports enthusiasts to prevent future conflicts. Red-Van Rooyen's bravery in coming forward and testifying has drawn attention to the issue of safety and conduct in shared water spaces.