BBC Sport's Rugby Special pundits John Barclay and Chris Ashton engaged in a lively debate ahead of the Calcutta Cup clash at Murrayfield. The former teammates selected their combined England and Scotland starting XV, with Ashton's controversial choices leaving Barclay visibly stunned.

As the Six Nations approaches its climax, the Calcutta Cup match between England and Scotland carries significant implications for both teams' championship hopes. Murrayfield will host what promises to be a fiercely contested battle between these historic rivals. The pundits' team selection highlighted the depth of talent on both sides and sparked discussion about key positional battles.

Ashton's picks, described as leaving Barclay 'speechless,' suggest the former England winger sees the game unfolding in an unexpected way. With both nations vying for Six Nations glory, this weekend's encounter could prove pivotal in determining the tournament's outcome.