Folarin Balogun's transfer to Everton collapsed on deadline day, capping a wild day for the USMNT striker. He arrived at Liverpool John Lennon Airport around 1:30 p.m. local time, later than expected, and went to Finch Farm for a medical ahead of a $54 million move. A "significant issue" in the medical emerged around 7 p.m., and despite a two-hour grace period and renegotiated terms, Balogun walked away just after midnight, unhappy with how the club handled his health concerns.

Monaco sporting director Thiago Scuro said Balogun felt uncomfortable signing a long contract after the medical team raised doubts. Everton blamed Monaco and Balogun for delays and poor communication, believing they lacked time to resolve the issue. The collapse hurt both clubs: Monaco needed the fee for finances, and Everton needed a striker after offloading Beto.

Balogun had been the USMNT's best player at the World Cup with three goals. The failed move leaves him at Monaco, while Gio Reyna's loan to Strasbourg may be his last chance. The window highlighted a frustrating summer for American players, with few high-profile moves completed.