Jon Wilkin, a former St Helens player, stated he is not surprised by the departure of head coach Paul Rowley after just nine months. Wilkin believes "the writing has been on the wall" for Rowley, citing declining fan attendance and "discord and vitriol" towards his appointment as key indicators. He noted a drop in average home attendance from 13,000 in 2024 to 11,000 in 2025, and a significantly low turnout for a recent game at Wigan.

Wilkin described the situation as a "bizarre time" for the club, expressing sadness over the current state of his former team, which recently won four consecutive championships. He suggested the club needs a "big personality" to re-engage fans and players.

Meanwhile, Sam Tomkins found the timing of Rowley's dismissal "horrendous," occurring the day before a crucial derby match against Wigan. Tomkins acknowledged that while St Helens are currently in playoff contention, the manner of their losses may have prompted the decision. He suggested a coaching change can sometimes galvanize players but acknowledged it's a significant gamble.