Jamie Redknapp and Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink debated whether Arsenal's Viktor Gyokeres should have been flagged offside for their opener against Chelsea in the Carabao Cup semi-final. The discussion followed Antoine Semenyo's disallowed goal for Newcastle, raising questions about consistency in officiating decisions.

Arsenal's goal came during a high-stakes cup tie, where marginal calls can swing momentum. The Premier League's VAR protocols are designed to eliminate clear errors, but interpretations of offside remain subjective. Fans and pundits alike demand clarity, especially when similar incidents produce different outcomes across competitions.

With the tie finely poised, the controversy adds pressure on officials ahead of the second leg. Both managers will likely reference the incident in pre-match briefings. The FA may review the decision to ensure future consistency, though no formal appeal is expected given the competition's rules.