With the 2026 Stanley Cup playoffs approaching, NHL fans whose teams are eliminated are searching for new teams to support. ESPN's Arda Ocal ranks the top five potential bandwagon destinations based on their playoff chances and fan appeal. The rankings consider factors like star power, franchise history, and the likelihood of making a deep postseason run.

Leading the list are the Buffalo Sabres at 99.9% playoff probability, ending a 14-year drought that held the dubious record for longest playoff absence in professional sports. Matthew Schaefer has emerged as the centerpiece of their resurgence, breaking numerous rookie and franchise records. The Minnesota Wild follow closely at 99.9%, representing a potential golden era for Minnesota hockey despite facing brutal Central Division competition.

Rounding out the top five are the New York Islanders (62.4%), Columbus Blue Jackets (68.3%), and San Jose Sharks (40.4%). Each offers unique appeal: the Islanders feature rookie sensation Schaefer, the Blue Jackets have passionate Columbus hockey fans and a touching connection to late Johnny Gaudreau, while the Sharks boast sophomore star Macklin Celebrini and exciting young talent. The Sharks' 40.4% chance makes them the riskiest but potentially most rewarding bandwagon pick.