HeadlinesBriefing HeadlinesBriefing 3 languages

The Social Reckoning is a timely reminder that we shouldn't trust Meta

Engadget ·

🇬🇧 English

The Social Reckoning serves as a timely reminder that we shouldn't trust Meta. While not a straightforward sequel to The Social Network, the film acts as a social media spin on All the President's Men. It chronicles the Wall Street Journal's investigation into Facebook, which culminated in the Pulitzer Prize-winning 2022 series "The Facebook Files." These revelations showed the company knew how badly Instagram affected teen girls' mental health and that its algorithm pushed users toward extremist content.

As Meta pushes further into our lives with its Muse AI assistant and surveillance glasses, and faces a potential $40 billion fine for lying about the Cambridge Analytica scandal, the film underscores why distrust is warranted. The narrative follows Jeff Horowitz (Jeremy Allen White), an investigative reporter with little tech experience, who contacts Frances Haugen (Mikey Madison), a Facebook engineer in its Civic Integrity Team. Haugen discovered Facebook radicalized her formerly progressive friend into a white supremacist.

Though a true believer in tech's mission to connect the world, she became disillusioned as that mission drifted toward engagement at any cost. She ultimately delivered the documents behind "The Facebook Files" and testified before a Congressional committee in 2021, warning that choices inside Facebook are disastrous for children, public safety, privacy, and democracy. The film jumps between the start of the WSJ investigation and 2021, depicting an expressionless Mark Zuckerberg (Jeremy Strong) preparing for another Congressional grilling.

In a pivotal scene referenced in "The Facebook Files," he ignores Haugen's team's findings on reducing misinformation because action would hurt user engagement. The climax covers the January 6th Capitol riot and Zuckerberg's reluctant decision to ban Trump's Facebook accounts. Last year, Meta paid Trump $25 million to settle a lawsuit over that ban.

Though it may not match The Social Network's cultural impact, it is a valuable reminder that Meta has gone to extraordinary lengths to prioritize profit over people.

View original article →


🇪🇸 Español

El Sospechoso Social Advierte Contra Confiar en Meta

El Sospechoso Social sirve como un recordatorio oportuno de que no debemos confiar en Meta. Aunque no es una secuela directa de The Social Network

Español version →


🇨🇳 简体中文

《社交警钟警告不要轻信Meta》

《社交警钟》是一个及时提醒,我们不应轻信Meta。虽然它并非《社交网络》的直接续集,但这部影片作为社交媒体版《总统班底》,记录了《华尔街日报》对Facebook的调查,最终导致2022年获得普利策奖的《Facebook Files》系列报道。这些披露显示公司清楚Instagram对青少年心理健康的负面影响,且其算法推动用户接触极端内容。随着Meta推进其Muse AI助手和监视眼镜,并面临因撒谎Cambridge Analytica丑闻而可能被处以400亿美元罚款的风险,影片凸显了不信任的必要性。故事线跟随Jeff Horowitz(Jeremy Allen White)这位经验丰富的调查记者,他对科技一知半解,却联系上Frances Haugen(Mikey Madison),她是Meta Civic Integrity Team的一名工程师。Haugen发现Meta将她曾经进步的朋友极端化为白人至上主义者。尽管她曾热忱相信科技连接世界的使命,但当该使命转向不惜一切代价追求参与度时,她逐渐失望。她最终交出了《Facebook Files》背后的文件,并在2021年向国会委员会作证,警告称Facebook内部的选择对儿童、公共安全、隐私和民主都造成灾难性后果。影片在《Facebook Files》中提到的一个关键场景里,展现了表情僵硬的Mark Zuckerberg(Jeremy Strong)准备应对另一次国会听证会,而他忽视了Haugen团队关于降低误导性信息的发现,因为这会影响用户参与度。高潮部分涵盖了1月6日国会山暴动,以及Zuckerberg勉强决定封禁特朗普的Facebook账号。去年,Meta向特朗普支付2500万美元,以此和解因封禁账号引发的诉讼。尽管它可能无法与《社交网络》媲美其文化影响力,但它是一个重要提醒:Meta不惜付出巨大代价,将利润置于人之上。

《社交警钟》关于Meta的核心信息是什么?

《社交警钟》认为Meta将利润和参与度置于用户安全、心理健康、民主与公共安全之上,尽管宣称能连接世界。它揭露了公司内部对Instagram危害青少年的了解,以及算法助长极端主义,最终引发1月6日国会山暴动以及因误导公众而被处以的巨额罚款。

简体中文 version →