Google finally launched a new Home Speaker after five years, but the audio quality disappoints. The device uses just a single tiny full-range driver for all sound output, which puts it behind dedicated speaker systems.

Amazon's Echo Studio offers a compelling alternative with genuine audiophile credentials. It packs three full-range drivers, a 3.75-inch high-excursion woofer, and supports Dolby Atmos with spatial audio. The smart speaker also doubles as a mesh Wi-Fi extender, adding coverage for up to 1,000 square feet when paired with an Eero router.

Prime Day pricing drops the Echo Studio to $175, saving 20% off its regular price. Four microphones ensure voice pickup even during loud music playback, while Alexa handles voice commands with optional Alexa Plus subscription available. The device supports Zigbee, Matter, and Thread protocols.

For anyone wanting room-filling sound from a smart speaker, the Echo Studio delivers where Google's offering falls short. The $75 premium over the basic Google model pays for serious audio hardware and smart home capabilities that justify the investment during this limited-time deal.