MAGA Christianity has rebranded empathy as weakness, with conservative commentators releasing books like 'Toxic Empathy' and 'The Sin of Empathy.' This shift concerns religious scholars who see it contradicting Jesus's teachings of compassion and radical love for others.

The anti-empathy movement gained prominence during the 2024 election, with figures like Elon Musk declaring empathy a fundamental weakness of Western civilization. Critics argue this doctrine helps justify political positions against helping marginalized groups while maintaining theological legitimacy.

Religious scholars point to biblical examples of Jesus's empathy, including his weeping and his teaching to love neighbors as oneself. They warn this trend represents a departure from Christianity's foundation, potentially alienating younger generations seeking faith rooted in compassion rather than political alignment.