BBC Sport gathered opinions from former players and pundits on who should succeed Steve Clarke as Scotland manager. The consensus leans heavily toward Ange Postecoglou, with Tommy expressing concerns about his recent record while Neil and Gordon praise his winning mentality and attacking philosophy. Most contributors want a shift away from defensive tactics.

Several names surface repeatedly in the discussion. Postecoglou receives the most backing despite mixed feelings about his current form. Kasper Hjulmand and Jurgen Klinsmann emerge as viable foreign options, while pundits like Thomas Frank and Roberto Martinez also get mentions. The underlying theme suggests Scottish football needs fresh tactical ideas rather than sticking with familiar faces.

Former internationals Darren Fletcher, Scott Brown and Callum Davidson represent the home-grown shortlist. However, many believe the lack of outstanding Scottish candidates means looking abroad is necessary. Ange Postecoglou dominates the conversation, with his World Cup experience and goal-scoring approach seen as ideal for transforming Scotland's fortunes ahead of their Euro 2028 hosting duties.

Critics argue the Scottish FA should conduct a proper recruitment process instead of defaulting to usual suspects. The recurring criticism of Scottish coaches being 'too fearful and pragmatic' indicates fans want a bolder approach, potentially from Scandinavian managers who play proactive football.