BBC Sport pundits have unveiled their ideal England XI ahead of Thomas Tuchel’s first World Cup lineup against Croatia. Goalkeeper Jordan Pickford receives unanimous nod, while the back line features Reece James if fully fit, John Stones over Ezri Konsa and the in‑form Nico O’Reilly at left. The selections aim to balance defensive solidity with possession control.

Midfield choices lean on Elliot Anderson for his ball‑winning and forward thrust, alongside Declan Rice whose presence remains non‑negotiable. Jude Bellingham anchors the number‑10 role, praised as a ‘big‑game’ player capable of dictating tempo. The pundits also slot Marcus Rashford on the wing, preferring him to Anthony Gordon for his incisive runs.

Up front, the consensus is clear: Harry Kane leads the line, with Bukayo Saka supporting from the flank. The proposed XI blends experience and youth, reflecting England’s desire to control possession while retaining a lethal edge. Should Tuchel adopt a similar formation, the squad could present a cohesive unit capable of challenging Croatia’s midfield dominance in the group stage.

Fans and analysts will compare these selections with Tuchel’s eventual choice, gauging whether the coach values the pundits’ emphasis on ball‑play over his own tactical instincts. The lineup will also influence squad morale ahead of the knockout rounds, as players vie for limited spots and aim to cement their places before the tournament’s climax.