HeadlinesBriefing favicon HeadlinesBriefing.com

KIDS Act Mandates Age Verification for All Online Users

Hacker News •
×

Congress prepares to vote on the KIDS Act within days, bundling revised Kids Online Safety Act with multiple internet regulations. The package forces platforms to implement age-gating across services using inconsistent standards and a negligence-style legal threshold. Companies face lawsuits if they fail to identify minors, creating pressure to verify all users rather than risk liability.

The bill's technical burden requires services to determine user ages under a "knows or should have known" standard, essentially mandating universal age checks. Current age-estimation systems misidentify children at high rates, with higher error rates for people of color, disabled individuals, and LGBTQ+ users. Platforms may resort to collecting driver's licenses or passport data to avoid legal exposure, fundamentally altering how users access online services.

Despite removing the controversial "duty of care" provision, the legislation still pressures platforms to moderate broad categories of lawful speech around drugs, gambling, and financial fraud. Young people discussing addiction recovery or seeking help for family members could trigger content restrictions. Legal risk incentivizes over-censorship, chilling legitimate conversations that happen to touch regulated topics.

Private messaging faces similar constraints through provisions governing direct messages and ephemeral content. While claiming not to override encryption, the bill demands platforms address harms within encrypted communications without specifying how. Services may weaken privacy protections or limit features to comply. The result is reduced privacy for all users, not just minors, as platforms implement blanket restrictions rather than nuanced age-based policies.