Jamie Carragher believes Manchester City should be stripped of titles won between 2009/10 and 2017/18 due to financial breaches, and that the club's owners must be removed from their positions. City have been found guilty of all charges by an independent commission and will appeal the ruling by October 2. During that period, City won three Premier League titles, one FA Cup, three League Cups, and one Community Shield.

Carragher argues that while trophies may be vacated, the emotional impact of winning—'the feeling at the time'—has been permanently robbed from players and fans. He insists the punishment must extend to ownership, stating the club's leaders have shown a pattern of defying accountability. Despite City's denial and appeal plans, Carragher maintains the reputational damage is severe and lasting, asserting that no medal can restore the lost experience of genuine victory.