ESPN's Seth Walder released his annual 100-player ballot for the 2025 NFL season, crowning Drake Maye as his MVP pick over Rams quarterback Matthew Stafford. Walder's analysis leans on advanced metrics, with Maye leading QBR (77.2) and setting a record for completion percentage over expectation. The list ranks players by value relative to their position, explaining the quarterback-heavy top tier.

Walder argues Maye's case is stronger due to his supporting cast, lacking a star receiver or elite play-caller. He points to Maye's high scramble rate and explosive plays, which compensated for a weaker offensive line and running game. The exercise highlights the challenge of valuing players in a team sport, especially when traditional MVP voting often prioritizes wins over individual impact.

Dak Prescott, despite a 7-9-1 record for Dallas, earns the second spot, challenging the win-centric MVP narrative. The full top 100 aims to answer questions about non-QB value, from centers to safeties. With the official MVP announcement coming February 5th, Walder's analytical approach provides a data-driven counterpoint to traditional voter perspectives.