Indianapolis confronts a trio of contract decisions, with running back Jonathan Taylor, guard Quenton Nelson, and defensive tackle DeForest Buckner all entering 2026 final years. The Colts have paid them $277.9 million combined, leaving the franchise to weigh performance, health, and market trends.

Taylor, 27, returned from injury to rush for 1,585 yards and 18 touchdowns in 2025, a season where the league began rewarding elite backs with higher pay. His current deal averages $14 million a year, a figure that could shift if the Colts pursue a new extension before free agency.

Nelson, 30, remains an eight‑time Pro Bowler and the highest‑paid guard in NFL history. The Colts likely want him as the offensive line anchor in 2027, while Buckner’s recent neck surgery and age raise doubts about his long‑term impact. The trio’s fates will shape the Colts’ 2026 roster and budget.