Mariano Rivera, the Yankees' career saves leader, returned to Old-Timers' Day after tearing an Achilles tendon in 2025. At 56, he threw 11 pitches to four batters, including former teammate Jorge Posada, and faced legends like Mickey Rivers. Rivera, who underwent surgery for the injury, expressed optimism: *'They're still moving'*. He also hit an inside-the-park homer in 2019 and participated in an at-bat against Mike Stanton. The event honored John Sterling, who died in May, and featured first-time attendees like David Weathers. Rivera’s 1996 World Series contributions, including the final pitch against the Phillies in 2021, were highlighted.

The ceremony included 11 1996 World Series players, such as Bernie Williams and Paul O'Neill, and manager Joe Torre. Rivera’s resilience mirrored his 1996 team’s mantra: *'We never gave up.'* Despite a 652 regular-season saves and 42 postseason in his career, his 2024 World Series loss to the Dodgers marked New York’s last title. The event began with a tribute to Sterling and included widows of Billy Martin, Thurman Munson, and Bobby Murcer.

Rivera’s injury history includes an ACL tear in 2012, but he returned for his final 2013 season. His 2026 appearance, introduced like Joe Di Maggio, concluded with a Metallica rendition of *'Enter Sandman'*. The Yankees’ 1996 team overcame a 12-1 deficit against the Braves, a story Rivera credited to relentless effort. Current YES Network broadcasters Dellin Betances, Todd Frazier, and Adam Ottavino attended for the first time.

Rivera’s legacy as a closer and his ability to perform under pressure remain central to Yankees lore. His 2026 return symbolizes both his enduring impact and the event’s role in celebrating baseball history.