Who really won the 2026 MLB trade deadline? We asked a panel of major league scouts and execs to weigh in on the biggest deals.

On the Dodgers acquiring Tarik Skubal: An NL scout was upset "the same story had to be defended again," noting the best org has the players to get deals done. An AL exec said, "I'm glad we're not in the NL." Most agreed Los Angeles was the high bidder because they can retain him via extension. On the Tigers' return: Scouts called it solid for a rental. Zyhir Hope is a "legit centerpiece type," while River Ryan could help soon. Brady Smith has trended up post-elbow rehab, drawing Walker Buehler comparisons.

On the Red Sox trading for Adley Rutschman: An NL scout was surprised by the prospect payment for a player "nowhere near the player he was since the 2024 All-Star break." An AL exec wasn't surprised, calling it a "when, not if" after hearing Baltimore chatter. Favorite other deals: Ryan Zeferjahn to the Cubs (need bat-missers), Giants adding Ramon Marquez and Miguel Mendez for pitching depth, and Blue Jays landing Jose Soriano — a creative move for controllable starting pitching.

Most improved: Dodgers, Blue Jays (Soriano, Spencer Arrighetti), Padres or Cubs (two legit starters). Teams that should've done more: Braves, A's, Royals.