The five owners of Florida-based EverBank clashed over its strategy after their 2023 purchase, highlighting tensions among private-equity firms seeking an exit three years later.

Initial optimism following the acquisition has given way to disagreements about how to maximize returns. Some stakeholders favor a rapid sale, while others push for continued growth and restructuring.

The dispute underscores broader challenges facing private-equity portfolios in volatile markets. Firms are under pressure to deliver returns to limited partners within typical holding periods.

EverBank's leadership has attempted to mediate discussions, but no consensus has emerged on timing or valuation expectations. Analysts note that similar conflicts have surfaced across regional banking assets acquired during the previous credit cycle.