Former Scotland internationals have delivered mixed assessments of Steve Clarke's position following the World Cup campaign. Willie Miller acknowledged below-par performances across three games, criticizing the lack of a top-class striker and questioning selection logic. However, Miller backed Clarke by emphasizing he achieved the primary objective.

Clarke secured Scotland's place at the tournament, delivering their first World Cup win in 28 years and first victory since 1990. Defeats to Morocco and Brazil exposed defensive frailties, with James McFadden describing the errors as costly and below expected standards. Pat Nevin suggested Clarke might consider walking away given the criticism, though he praised the squad's improved togetherness.

Stephen O'Donnell defended Clarke's tenure, pointing to progression made over seven years and noting Group C featured two of the world's top teams. Scotland advanced despite conceding soft early goals, while Cape Verde progressed with just three draws from an easier group. The Motherwell defender emphasized momentum building within the national setup.

Clarke's record speaks volumes - 81 matches in charge and qualification for three of the last four major tournaments. While questions persist about playing style and defensive organization, the Scotland manager has delivered tangible progress. Whether supporters accept this as sufficient remains the central debate.